I apologize for the fact that this review feels a bit scattered, but I wanted to put my thoughts down before I went to bed. You see the things I do for books I love.
Title:
It Had to Be You Author: Susan Elizabeth Phillips
Genre: Contemporary romance
Grade: A
Synopsis: TWO HEARTS COLLIDE
The Windy City isn't quite ready for Phoebe Somerville—the trendy, outrageous and
curvaceous New York knockout who has just inherited the Chicago Stars football team.
And Phoebe is
definitely
not prepared for the Stars' head coach Dan Calebo—an Alabama-born former gridiron
legend and blond barbarian.
Calebo is everything Phoebe abhors—a sexist, jock taskmaster with a one-track mind.
The beautiful new boss is everything Dan despises—a meddling bimbo who doesn't know
pigskin from a pitcher's mound. So why is he drawn to the shameless sexpot like a
heat-seeking missile? And why does Dan's good ol' boy charm leave cosmopolitan Phoebe
feeling awkward, tongue-tied and frightened to death?
Suddenly there's more than just a championship at stake. Because passion's the name
of
this game—and two stubborn people are playing for keeps!
My Thoughts: Like most of Susan Elizabeth Phillips's books, this one has a summary that screams "Wacky hijinks found here!" However, people on my romance discussion group were shocked and appalled that I hadn't read a SEP book before, and so, since this one has appeared on my librarything suggester, I figured why not. I never expected to love it.
What we have here is an exciting story with fully realized characters. In most other authors' hands, Phoebe and Dan would have been reduced to caricatures. But here I believed what SEP did, and I loved watching the struggle these two had to find love.
Phoebe was a wonderful character. She acts outrageously to cover up for some horribly traumatic things that have happened to her in her past. I'm sure some readers would question her motivations, but they worked for me. And Phoebe, like me, has a thing for nerds. Even though Dan is a jock, she is also drawn to him because he's definitely a smart man. I also liked watching Phoebe struggle to come to terms with her father's bullying and manipulations and to establish closeness with her sister.
As for Dan, well, he's just as well-drawn. He has been married to a state legislator, but the marriage didn't work out, and now he just wants to find someone who wants to settle down and raise his children. I liked that though he was an alpha male, he wasn't so much in control of every situation, although I do have to say that his ex-wife was a completely sleazy bitch. Ugh, the sex scene we got with her was seriously squick-making.
The romance was wonderful and well-paced, and during the inevitable moments near the end when it looks like things might not work out, I was tense and practically biting my nails to see what SEP would do to resolve everything. Which I'm glad to report that she does, rather neatly.
My quibbles are minor. The villains were definitely not as well-drawn as any of our protagonists, and sometimes I thought SEP went over the top with them. But the fact that she didn't descend into camp and stereotypes with the rest of the characters makes up for that.
I would recommend this book. I breezed through it while waiting for a ride home from the store and kept reading until nearly 2 A.M., which is something I don't often do, thanks to my tendency to get distracted by shiny objects. SEP does wonderful romantic comedy, and I cannot wait to read the sequels to this book.